OptionsKing

Covered calls compared with holding shares

Compare total outcomes on equal starting holdings and understand the limits of strategy benchmarks.

By OptionsKing. Publisher and editorial methods.

What you will learn

By the end of this lesson, you should be able to:

  1. Calculate matched total returns.
  2. Locate where stock ownership overtakes the call strategy.
  3. Explain what a benchmark does and does not represent.

A covered call changes the payoff of a stock holding. Its premium helps relative to shares alone in some outcomes, while its sale commitment limits participation in a sufficiently large rally. Comparing the strategies requires total results from the same starting capital and dates.

Construct a matched comparison

Suppose two accounts each begin with 100 fictional Harbor shares bought for $50, a $5,000 investment. One account simply holds the shares. The other sells one standard $55 call for $2.00 per share. Measure both at the same call expiration and exclude dividends, costs, interest, and taxes.

For this comparison, assume calls above the strike are assigned at expiration and calls below the strike expire unexercised. The table records economic expiration values; actual exercise procedures must be checked separately.

Profit or loss on the same initial shares
Ending stock priceHolding sharesCovered call
$40-$1,000-$800
$50$0+$200
$55+$500+$700
$57+$700+$700
$65+$1,500+$700

Read both directions

At $40, the call strategy loses $800 compared with $1,000 for stock alone. It performs $200 better while still losing money. Relative outperformance is therefore not the same as a positive return.

At $57, both strategies gain $700. Above $57, the uncapped shares earn more than this covered call. At $65, holding stock gains $1,500 while the covered call remains at $700, a difference of $800.

The $57 crossover equals the $55 strike plus $2 premium in this simplified example. It depends on the selected contract and costs; it is not a prediction that the stock will reach that price.

Understand a published benchmark

The Cboe S&P 500 BuyWrite Index, called BXM, represents a rules-based strategy that holds S&P 500 exposure and writes monthly at-the-money calls. It can illustrate the behavior of that defined approach across market periods.

BXM does not represent every covered-call choice. An investor using individual stocks, different strikes, different dates, or discretionary rolls has different exposures. Index results also follow specified calculation and cost assumptions; they are not executable account statements.

Measure repeated strategies fairly

Across many periods, include dividends, option buybacks, share sales and repurchases, cash interest, and costs. Use matching total-return benchmarks and dates. Premium collected by itself cannot establish that the call strategy improved performance.

Check your understanding

What must be compared to judge the two strategies?

Let's walk through the answer.

Both the shares and option results must be measured consistently.

Sources

Rules and thresholds above were checked against these documents on October 22, 2026. Exchange and broker rules change. Confirm anything you are about to act on with your own broker.

Keep reading

Do the math on your own trade

Every price in this article is an illustrative worked example, not a quote. Read Covered calls for the rest of the series, and the disclaimer before you act on any of it. Selling options carries real risk of loss, and the loss can be far larger than the premium you collected.