OptionsKing

Small premiums and large possible losses

Compare a small option credit with trading costs, committed capital, and the losses that can occur in an unfavorable outcome.

By OptionsKing. Publisher and editorial methods.

What you will learn

By the end of this lesson, you should be able to:

  1. Calculate premium after fees.
  2. Compare a stress loss with repeated small gains.
  3. Include the treatment of reserved cash.

An out-of-the-money put can have a small premium because its purchase right is currently unattractive to exercise. Moving farther from the stock price can reduce the premium further. A small credit does not make the seller's purchase obligation small.

Measure the credit after costs

Suppose fictional Harbor shares trade at $50 and a standard $40 put sells for $0.20 per share. The seller receives $20 and accepts a possible $4,000 share purchase. Assume $2 of fees for a trade that expires without exercise. The net gain in that outcome is $18.

Relative to the full $4,000 reserve, $18 is a 0.45% return for that particular holding period. It is not a yearly return or a promise that the next period produces the same gain. A closing purchase or additional fees would reduce the result.

Compare a larger adverse outcome

If the stock is $30 at expiration, the $40 put has $1,000 of exercise value per contract. After the $20 premium and assumed $2 fees, the loss is $982. The stock can fall farther, so this is a stress case rather than the maximum loss.

Fifty-four $18 gains total $972, which is still less than the $982 loss. This arithmetic illustrates the imbalance between small gains and a larger loss. It does not state how often either outcome will occur.

A probability estimate is only one input

Even a contract with a high estimated chance of expiring without exercise can have an unfavorable average result if its losses are sufficiently large. A full evaluation needs both possible amounts and their probabilities, as well as execution costs.

A quoted model probability is not an observed success rate. Company events, jumps in the stock price, and changing market conditions can produce outcomes that a simple model describes poorly. Later probability lessons develop these limits.

Include the cash treatment

Reserved cash may or may not earn interest, depending on the broker and collateral arrangement. If it earns the same interest as an available cash alternative, that interest is common to both choices. If it does not, forgone interest belongs in the comparison.

Compare net option compensation with the additional obligation and any difference in cash earnings. A larger premium is not automatically better either; the associated risk and committed capital may also be larger.

Check your understanding

Does a small premium make the purchase obligation equally small?

Let's walk through the answer.

The strike and contract size determine the share-purchase obligation.

Sources

Rules and thresholds above were checked against these documents on October 21, 2026. Exchange and broker rules change. Confirm anything you are about to act on with your own broker.

Keep reading

Do the math on your own trade

Every price in this article is an illustrative worked example, not a quote. Read Portfolio risk and records for the rest of the series, and the disclaimer before you act on any of it. Selling options carries real risk of loss, and the loss can be far larger than the premium you collected.