Comparing covered calls with holding shares
Compare the same shares over the same period and see how a covered call changes the result in rising, flat, and falling markets.
By OptionsKing. Publisher and editorial methods.
What you will learn
By the end of this lesson, you should be able to:
- Construct a comparison using matching starting capital.
- Calculate both strategies at several expiration prices.
- Explain why one scenario cannot establish long-term superiority.
A strategy comparison needs a consistent starting point. The same stock, starting share value, measurement dates, and cash-flow treatment should be used. Otherwise, differences caused by timing or position size may be mistaken for benefits of the option strategy.
Define the two positions
In a hypothetical example, both investors begin with 100 Harbor shares bought for $50 each. One simply holds the shares. The other sells one $55 call for $2.00 per share, receiving $200. Compare both positions at the call's expiration, with no dividends, interest, fees, or taxes.
The stock-only result is the ending share value minus $5,000. The covered-call result adds the $200 premium and subtracts the call's exercise value. At or above the $55 strike, the covered-call gain is capped at $700.
Compare several ending prices
If Harbor finishes at $50, holding shares breaks even while the covered call gains $200. If it finishes at $60, holding shares gains $1,000 while the covered call gains $700. If it finishes at $40, holding shares loses $1,000 while the covered call loses $800.
The premium improves the result by $200 in the flat and falling examples. In the rising example, the $300 difference favors holding shares. That difference is forgone gain for the covered-call investor; the covered call still made a positive $700 result.
| Stock price | Hold shares | Covered call |
|---|---|---|
| $40 | -$1,000 | -$800 |
| $50 | $0 | +$200 |
| $55 | +$500 | +$700 |
| $60 | +$1,000 | +$700 |
Keep the comparison fair over time
If assignment sells the shares, the covered-call account subsequently holds cash unless another transaction occurs. Buying shares again at a new price changes the next period's starting point. A multi-period comparison must specify those reinvestment decisions.
Include dividends, interest on cash, transaction costs, and any deposits or withdrawals consistently. Compare percentage returns using the same capital base. Measuring one strategy from an old purchase price and the other from a recent price mixes different periods.
Interpret the evidence
One chosen path cannot establish which strategy will outperform over many future periods. A backtest also depends on its rules, data, execution assumptions, and market history. Report the periods and risks examined alongside the return.
The stable conclusion is about the payoff: a covered call exchanges some possible upside for premium while retaining substantial stock downside. Whether that trade-off suits an objective requires more than a favorable example.
Check your understanding
What should be matched in a fair strategy comparison?
Let's walk through the answer.
Matching the starting conditions separates strategy effects from sizing and timing differences.
Sources
Rules and thresholds above were checked against these documents on October 22, 2026. Exchange and broker rules change. Confirm anything you are about to act on with your own broker.
Keep reading
Do the math on your own trade
Every price in this article is an illustrative worked example, not a quote. Read Portfolio risk and records for the rest of the series, and the disclaimer before you act on any of it. Selling options carries real risk of loss, and the loss can be far larger than the premium you collected.